PR9.NET| Home | |
Submit Press Release | |
Search Archives |
| PR9.NET |
|
 |
 Business
 Computers
Entertainment
Games
Health
Home
Science
Sports
Society
Teens |
Park West Gallery Throws in the Towel in Defamation Counterclaim Against Customers Who Sued the Gallery for Fraud
Park West Gallery voluntarily dismissed its own counterclaim of defamation against customers who sued the gallery for fraud and other counts. This follows a Case Evaluation which awarded Park West Gallery $0 for its claims while awarding close to $350,000 to the plaintiffs/customers who sued Park West alleging that they had fraudulently sold inauthentic and overpriced art . The suit filed by Park West customers against Park West Gallery proceeds to trial. PR9.NET December 03, 2009 - DETROIT, MI, USA - On November 30th, 2009, Hon. Nanci J. Grant, Circuit Judge of Oakland, State of Michigan, ordered the dismissal with prejudice of Park West Gallery's Counter-Complaint against Counter-Defendants Julian Howard and Sharon Day after Park West Gallery attorneys approached counsel for Day and Howard, to announce the gallery's voluntary dismissal of the case (Case No. 08-096952-CZ). Park West Gallery had previously dismissed its counter-claims against Counter-Defendants Michael and Maria Vallillo and Cheryl Crist in the same case. Sharon Day and Julian Howard were among the ten plaintiffs who initially sued Park West Gallery, Albert Scaglione, Morris Shapiro and Royal Caribbean Cruises, Ltd. on December 23rd, 2008 for Violation of Michigan's Warranty in Fine Arts Statute, Fraud, Violation of the Michigan Consumer Protection Act, Breach of Contract, Violation of the Michigan Art Multiples Act, Negligent Misrepresentation, Conspiracy and Unjust Enrichment. A month later Park West retaliated against eight of these, its own customers who had sued them, by filing a Counterclaim alleging defamation, tortious interference and civil conspiracy. But a Case Evaluation on November 17th (in which both sides are heard and the panel comes up with figures they believe the case should settle for) awarded Park West Gallery $0 in damages in their Counterclaim. Now, with two days to go before the Counter-Defendants' Motion to Dismiss was due to come before Judge Grant, Park West Gallery attorneys approached Sharon Day and Julian Howard's attorneys,, with an offer to dismiss the case. The same Case Evaluation awarded Park West Gallery $0 in its Third-Party Claims against Fine Art Registry and Frank Hunter in the same case. The Case Evaluation awarded the Plaintiffs a total of $347,900 in damages against Park West Gallery. The news of the dismissal was eagerly received by Sharon Day who said: "My husband and I feel completely vindicated by this result. For nearly a year, we have lived under the stress and strain of not only being counter-sued for defamation, civil conspiracy and interference with business opportunity, but also of not being told what the supposed defamatory statements were, who we were supposed to have conspired with and about what, or what business opportunity we supposedly interfered with. Now, no doubt still stinging from the recent Case Evaluation result awarding Park West exactly ZERO on said counter-claims, and with only a few days to spare before a Dismissal hearing when Park West would finally have to justify their claims – they voluntarily dismiss us. We therefore feel as though we have triumphed in a year-long battle against the proverbial playground bully and we look forward to yet another significant victory on our claim against Park West when we proceed to trial." Jim Raftery, Senior Partner with Raftery, Janeczek and Hoelscher, co-defense counsel for Counter-Defendants Sharon Day and Julian Howard, said: "We filed the Motion to Dismiss PWG's Claims on Oct. 21, 2009. The Dismissal hearing was set for Dec. 2, 2009, but just two days beforehand (on Nov.30, 2009) PWG agreed to dismiss their counter-claim 'with Prejudice' which, pursuant to Michigan law, means the claims of PWG asserted in this lawsuit are now barred for all time. My clients have always felt that this was vindictive litigation filed in an attempt to discourage them from prosecuting their own lawsuit against PWG." Donald Payton, Senior Partner of Kaufman, Payton & Chapa, commented on Park West's voluntary dismissal: "Finally a victory for the little guy! When Sharon Day and Julian Howard dared to bring a lawsuit against the almighty Park West Gallery for the gallery's sale of inauthentic art, they were immediately retaliated against by virtue of a baseless counter-claim being brought against them by Park West. However, after a court appointed case evaluation panel in Oakland County Circuit Court awarded Park West $0 on its counter-claim, and faced with a motion to dismiss the counter-claim, Park West threw in the proverbial towel and agreed to dismiss the counter-claim. It's a shame it took all this to get the correct result, but the focus is once again put back where it belongs: their lawsuit to be recompensed for their virtually worthless artwork." # # #
|
||||||||||||||||
Founded in 1975, Kaufman, Payton & Chapa, now has offices in Farmington Hills, Detroit and Grand Rapids and represents clients throughout the state of Michigan. Known for the aggressiveness and tenacity of it attorneys and its results-oriented approach to cases, the firm represents clients in trial and appellate matters large and small. For more information visit www.kaufmanlaw.com or contact Jonathan H. Schwartz – (248) 626 5000 JHSchwartz@kaufmanlaw.com. About Fine Art Registry Fine Art Registry™ is today's only high tech solution to the age old problems that have existed in the art world since before the Ancient Greeks: How to establish provenance, prove authenticity and ownership, prevent forgery and fakery, deter theft and, basically, make it possible to create, buy and sell works of art with the security of knowing that they are what they claim to be. If you are an artist, collector, gallery director, museum curator or anyone interested in making a permanent record of and protecting visual art and valuables, then you should find out what FAR® has to offer you. |
Recent News Headlines
|
|
| Industry Category of Current Press Release |
|
| Copyright © 2004 - 2008 PR9.NET - All rights reserved | | RSS Feeds | | Submit Press Release | | Terms of Service | | Privacy Policy |
